-
Did you pay more than 2.5% interest on your car in installments? GET YOUR MONEY BACK! Schedule a FREE chat with one of our specialists! Did you purchase your car in installments between 2007-2024? You are entitled to thousands of pounds back!
What can go wrong when you complain to your car finance lender
Edited by Adrian Defta
Many people are encouraged to complain directly to their car finance lender — and in many cases, this is the right first step.
However, not all complaints go smoothly.
This guide explains common issues people encounter when complaining about car finance mis-selling, what these responses usually mean, and how to approach them calmly and realistically.
Complaining directly is allowed — but not always simple
Consumers are entitled to complain directly to their car finance lender, without using a claims management company.
That said, lender responses can sometimes:
Feel unclear or dismissive
Create uncertainty about whether your situation qualifies
Raise new questions rather than solving the issue
Understanding these responses can help you avoid confusion or unnecessary escalation.
What if the lender does not respond at all
What does this look like?
No acknowledgment email or letter
Long delays with no updates
Missed response timeframes
What does this usually mean?
This does not automatically mean your complaint has been rejected.
Possible reasons include:
High volume of complaints
Administrative delays
Requests being logged but not yet reviewed
What to consider
Keep a record of when and how you complained
Check whether the lender has confirmed the receipt
Avoid submitting multiple complaints unless advised
Silence can be frustrating, but it is not a final outcome.
What if the lender responds by saying you "don't qualify"
Common wording people see
"Your agreement does not fall within the scope of our review"
"Discretionary commission was not used"
"Based on our records, no redress is due"
Why this can feel confusing
These responses often:
Use technical language
Do not explain why the conclusion was reached
Do not clarify what factors were considered
As a result, consumers may feel dismissed without understanding the reasoning.
Important context
A response stating that discretionary commission was not used does not automatically address:
Whether the agreement was clearly explained
Whether commission or incentives exist in another form
Whether other mis-selling concerns may apply
To understand the wider context, see:
👉 discretionary commission in car finance explained
What if the lender confirms commission — but delays next steps
What does this look like?
Some lenders may respond by:
Confirming that commission exists
Explaining how it worked
Asking whether you would like to proceed with a complaint
This can feel contradictory:
"If commission existed, why am I being asked what to do next?"
Why is this happening?
In some cases:
The lender is providing information before a formal complaint is advanced
The response is part of a staged process
The lender is seeking confirmation before continuing
This does not necessarily mean:
That redress will follow
That the complaint has been accepted
But it also doesn't close the door.
What if the response feels incomplete or selective
What people often notice
Only one issue addressed
No reference to how the finance was sold
No explanation of alternative rates or options
This can leave consumers unsure whether:
All relevant factors were considered
The response was based on a full review
In such cases, understanding what was reviewed can be as important as the outcome itself.
What if the response pushes you towards using a third party
Some responses may indirectly suggest:
Seeking external assistance
Using a representative
Getting "professional help"
It's important to know:
You are not required to use a claims management company
Complaints can be pursued directly
Independent guidance is an option before committing to any route
If you've already signed a CMC agreement and feel unsure, see:
👉 claims management company contracts - what you need to know
Does a difficult response mean my complaint has failed?
Not necessarily.
A challenging or unclear response does not automatically mean:
Your situation is invalid.
You have no options.
The process is over.
It often means that:
More clarity is needed.
The lender's reasoning should be better understood
Expectations should be reset
For the bigger picture, see:
👉 car finance mis-selling explained
Common mistakes to avoid
When dealing with lender responses, it may help to avoid:
Assuming silence means rejection
Interpreting technical wording too literally
Escalating without understanding the response
Signing third-party agreements in frustration
Taking time to understand the situation can prevent unnecessary complications.
What can help before taking the next step
Before doing anything else, consider:
Reviewing the lender's response carefully
Comparing it with your agreement
Understanding what was — and wasn't — addressed
This can help you decide whether:
Further clarification is needed
You're comfortable proceeding alone
Independent guidance would be useful
FAQs — lender responses
1. Why hasn't my lender replied yet?
Delays can happen due to volume or processing times. A lack of response does not automatically mean rejection.
2. What if my lender says discretionary commission was not used?
That addresses one factor only. Other aspects of how the agreement was explained may still be relevant.
3. Why would a lender confirm commission but not offer redress?
Confirmation of commission does not automatically lead to redress. Further assessment is often required.
4. Should I complain again if the response is unclear?
It may help to seek clarity before submitting further complaints or escalating.
5. Do I need to use a claims management company?
No. Consumers can complain directly and may also seek independent guidance first.
6. How can ProveIt help?
ProveIt does not submit complaints or act as a claims management company.
We help you:
Understand the type of car finance you used
See where misunderstandings may arise
Decide what questions to ask before taking next steps
👉 Help me understand my car finance agreement
General information only. No obligation.
Subscribe to Newsletter
ProveIt - the platform of informed Romanians
We already have over 20,000 subscribers. Sign up too!
Guide created by Adrian Defta based on his experience and official sources of information (MSE, FCA, FOS, HMRC, etc.)
By using the guides you agree to our privacy policy. For more details, please read the T&C.
Subscribing to the newsletter will keep you up to date with new ways to save money. You can unsubscribe at any time.