-
Did you pay more than 2.5% interest on your car in installments? GET YOUR MONEY BACK! Schedule a FREE chat with one of our specialists! Did you purchase your car in installments between 2007-2024? You are entitled to thousands of pounds back!
What is discretionary commission in car finance?
Edited by Adrian Defta
Discretionary commission has become a central issue in recent reviews of car finance practices.
However, many people who took out car finance were never told what it was — or that it could affect the deal they received.
This guide explains the discretionary commission in plain English, why it matters, and how it relates to wider concerns about car finance mis-selling.
General information only. No obligation.
What does "discretionary commission" mean?
In car finance, discretionary commission refers to a commission arrangement where a broker or dealer could influence the interest rate offered to a customer — and earn more commission if the rate was higher.
In simple terms:
The lender sets a range of possible interest rates
The dealer or broker could choose where within that range your rate landed
A higher interest rate could result in a higher commission for the intermediary
This arrangement was not always explained clearly to consumers at the time the finance was agreed.
How the discretionary commission worked in practice
When someone arranged car finance through a dealership, the focus was often on:
Monthly payments
Whether the car was affordable
Getting the deal approved quickly
What was not always explained was:
That the interest rate could vary
That the dealer might benefit financially from setting a higher rate
That alternative rates or structures might have existed
As a result, many consumers assumed the interest rate offered was fixed or set solely by the lender.
Why consumers often didn't know about it
In many cases, the discretionary commission was:
Buried in lender-dealer agreements
Referred to using technical language
Not discussed during sales conversations
Consumers were rarely told:
That commission existed
How it was calculated
That it could influence the cost of their finances
This lack of transparency is one reason the discretionary commission has attracted regulatory attention.
Why discretionary commission matters
Discretionary commission matters because it may affect:
The interest rate you paid
The total cost of your finance agreement
Whether you were given clear and fair information
The concern is not simply that the commission existed, but that consumers may not have been able to make an informed decision if key information was missing or unclear.
What has the FCA said about discretionary commission?
The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has raised concerns about discretionary commission arrangements in car finance.
In particular, the FCA has highlighted issues around:
Conflicts of interest
Lack of transparency
Whether customers were treated fairly
As a result, discretionary commission models of this type are no longer permitted in the same way they were in the past.
Importantly, this does not mean:
Every agreement was mis-sold
Every consumer is entitled to redress
Each case depends on its individual facts.
If you're unsure whether your situation relates to car finance mis-selling, it may help to understand the wider context first.
Does discretionary commission mean my finance was mis-sold?
Not necessarily.
Discretionary commission is one factor that may be relevant when assessing whether a car finance agreement was mis-sold.
Other factors may include:
What you were told at the time
Whether risks and costs were clearly explained
How the finance was presented
Whether key information was omitted
Which types of finance were affected?
Discretionary commission arrangements were most commonly associated with:
Personal Contract Purchase (PCP)
Hire Purchase (HP)
Dealer-arranged finance agreements
They were less common in:
Direct-to-lender applications
Personal loans arranged independently
The structure of the agreement — not just the product type — is what matters.
Which types of finance were affected?
Discretionary commission arrangements were most commonly associated with:
Personal Contract Purchase (PCP)
Hire Purchase (HP)
Dealer-arranged finance agreements
They were less common in:
Direct-to-lender applications
Personal loans arranged independently
The structure of the agreement — not just the product type — is what matters.
What can you do if this sounds familiar?
If you're unsure whether discretionary commission played a role in your agreement, a sensible first step is to:
Review your financial documents
Look at how the interest rate was described
Check whether commission or incentives were mentioned
You may also want to understand:
How complaints about car finance mis-selling work
Whether you've already signed a claims management company contract
Helpful guides:
👉 Claims management company contracts - what you need to know
Do I need a claims management company?
You are not required to use a claims management company to raise a complaint.
Consumers can:
Complain directly to lenders at no cost
Ask questions before taking any formal action
Seek independent guidance first
Using a claims management company does not guarantee a better outcome.
FAQs about discretionary commission
1. What is discretionary commission in simple terms?
It is a commission structure where a dealer or broker could earn more by setting a higher interest rate on a car finance agreement.
2. Is discretionary commission illegal?
Discretionary commission arrangements are no longer permitted in the same form, but that does not automatically make past agreements unlawful.
3. Does discretionary commission mean I paid too much?
Not always. Whether it affects what you pay depends on the specific agreement and how it was explained at the time.
4. Can I complain if discretionary commission was involved?
You can complain if you believe important information was not disclosed or the agreement was not explained fairly. Each complaint is assessed individually.
5. Do I need to act immediately?
There is no benefit in rushing without understanding your situation. Taking time to review your agreement can help avoid mistakes.
6. How can ProveIt help?
ProveIt does not submit claims or act as a claims management company.
We help you:
Understand how your car finance agreement works
See where the discretionary commission fits into the wider picture
Make informed decisions before taking further steps
👉 Help me understand my car finance agreement
General information only. No obligation.
Subscribe to Newsletter
ProveIt - the platform of informed Romanians
We already have over 20,000 subscribers. Sign up too!
Guide created by Adrian Defta based on his experience and official sources of information (MSE, FCA, FOS, HMRC, etc.)
By using the guides you agree to our privacy policy. For more details, please read the T&C.
Subscribing to the newsletter will keep you up to date with new ways to save money. You can unsubscribe at any time.